Ah, Cape Cod: the land of lighthouses, Kennedys, and lobster rolls. In recent years, this well-known summer destination has seen an influx of year-round residents, bringing an ever-growing list of excellent bars and restaurants, bakeries and breweries, and quality cultural events. If you’re planning a trip during the busy summer months, you’ll want to book your vacation rental early—some regulars reserve their summer homes as much as a year in advance. But if you ask any Cape Codder, there really is no bad time of year to visit this slice of New England paradise. Summers are great for outdoor adventures and time at the beach, while the off-season is perfect for bracing walks and cozy nights by the fire.
Here, we’ve found some of the best vacation rentals in Cape Cod, organized geographically from the Upper Cape (towns like Sandwich and Falmouth) to the Outer Cape (like beloved Provincetown). Whether you’re traveling with the whole family or enjoying a romantic couple’s weekend, there’s a home for everyone on this list—and plenty of quintessential cedar shake cottages to go around.
Looking for ideas for things to do on the 70-mile-long peninsula during your trip? We have a Cape Cod travel guide that covers where to eat and what to see while you’re there, whether you’re staying in Bourne or Brewster. Considering staying at a hotel instead? We have intel on those, too.
We’ve vetted these listings based on Superhost status, ratings, amenities, location, previous guest reviews, and decor. This article has been updated with new information since its original publish date.
All products featured on Condé Nast Traveler are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
